Your Ultimate Information Platform

Viewpoint: Why Twitter obtained it incorrect in Nigeria



A woman in Nigeria looking at Twitter on a mobile phone - archive shot

A lady in Nigeria taking a look at Twitter on a cell phone – archive shot

In our series of letters from African writers, Nigerian journalist and novelist Adaobi Tricia Nwaubani considers Twitter’s energy and the Nigerian authorities’s strikes to curb it.

Short presentational grey line

Brief presentational gray line

It has been two months because the Nigerian authorities banned Twitter after the tech large deleted a publish by President Muhammadu Buhari for violating its guidelines on abusive language.

Regardless of the worldwide outrage that adopted, together with robust phrases of condemnation from prime overseas diplomats within the nation, the federal government remained adamant.

Nonetheless, it introduced on Wednesday that it was finalising an settlement with Twitter and the ban can be lifted in a number of days or even weeks.

A man carries a banner during a demonstration at Ojota in Lagos on June 12, 2021, as Nigerian activists called for nationwide protests over what they criticise as bad governance and insecurity, as well as the recent ban of US social media platform Twitter by the government of President Muhammadu Buhari.

Many Nigerians have been angered by the Twitter ban

A lot of the remark that adopted on the time centered on the ban’s detrimental influence on freedom of speech and the economic system.

Many Nigerians use the platform to amplify their grievances in opposition to the federal government and to achieve extra prospects for his or her companies.

However Twitter’s resolution to delete President Buhari’s publish – through which he threatened violence in opposition to a separatist motion – was ill-advised. This has additionally grow to be some extent of debate in different components of the world, together with India.

The US-owned, personal agency gave the impression to be interfering within the inside affairs of a sovereign African state with out sufficient background information to grasp the implications of its actions.


On the time, Twitter stated the publish was in violation of its guidelines.

The corporate has the best to implement its rules, however Mr Buhari’s publish was an official communication from the Nigerian president to his folks, tweeted from a authorities account.

The identical message was additionally broadcast on different media platforms throughout the nation.

Is it proper {that a} personal American agency has the ability to edit, with out permission, the official communication of a democratically elected president of an African nation? It does not get any extra neo-colonial than that.

Leading opposition presidential candidate in forthcoming April polls and flag bearer of Congress for Progressive Change, retired General Muhammadu Buhari raises his hand to salute the crowd shortly on arrival to flag off his presidential campaign rally in Kaduna Wednesday, on March 2, 2011

President Muhammadu Buhari, 78, has been in workplace since 2015

Nigerians have the best to concentrate on their chief’s plans and methods, regardless of how reckless his alternative of phrases could be. They’ve a proper to know even when he’s planning one thing as heartless as unleashing violence on them.

Equally, Nigerians have the best to reply to him as a part of the interplay between the federal government and its residents.

Mr Buhari’s tweet threatened violence in opposition to the Indigenous Individuals of Biafra (Ipob) motion, which is looking for a breakaway state in south-eastern Nigeria, dwelling to the Igbo folks.

Ipob was outlawed in 2017 – the group fought the ban in courtroom and misplaced.

Amplifying divisions

Whereas many Igbos consider they’ve been marginalised in some ways, equivalent to being neglected of key nationwide management positions, the bulk don’t help Ipob’s want for secession.

Neither do they like its violent rhetoric in opposition to different ethnic teams – also known as wild animals by Ipob chief Nnamdi Kanu, who’s dealing with treason prices.

In February, Fb deactivated Mr Kanu’s account for its hate speech, however he remained lively on Twitter.

By deleting Mr Buhari’s threats, Twitter was inadvertently taking sides with Ipob, and the group’s supporters wasted no time in celebrating this assumed present of solidarity.

Following the backlash from the federal government in June, a number of of the Ipob chief’s tweets have been eliminated by Twitter.

Pro-Biafra supporters shout slogans in Aba, south-eastern Nigeria, during a protest calling for the release of a key activist on November 18, 2015

Some members of Nigeria’s minority Igbo ethnic group have waged a long-running marketing campaign for secession

Equally inconsiderate involvement by Twitter amplified the divisions that derailed Nigeria’s #EndSars motion that oversaw protests in opposition to police brutality in October 2020.

Totally different teams have been concerned in planning and fundraising for the protests that started on-line and poured into the streets of cities throughout Nigeria for about two weeks.

However when Twitter verified the account of 1 group and never of others, it led to bitter mudslinging and the withdrawal of some teams from the motion.

Twitter had inadvertently chosen the leaders of Nigeria’s social motion in opposition to police brutality and successfully escalated the rivalry that had already fractured the motion,” wrote Nigerian journalist Ohimai Amaize.

Try and stifle criticism

The tech large trod the place even seasoned overseas diplomats and international our bodies concern to go.

Many well-meaning outsiders have realized by no means to be too fast to meddle within the affairs of African international locations, like Nigeria, the place points are sometimes extra sophisticated than meets the attention. They’re more and more embracing the pattern of deferring duty to native organisations that higher perceive native dynamics.

Twitter’s resolution to arrange a West Africa headquarters in Ghana is an effective step in growing cultural competence.

"If it was authoritarian to ban Twitter, it was even more problematic for an American in Silicon Valley to poke their finger in the affairs of a sovereign state"", Source: Adaobi Tricia Nwaubani , Source description: Nigerian novelist, Image: Adaobi

“If it was authoritarian to ban Twitter, it was much more problematic for an American in Silicon Valley to poke their finger within the affairs of a sovereign state””, Supply: Adaobi Tricia Nwaubani , Supply description: Nigerian novelist, Picture: Adaobi

The Nigerian authorities’s situations for lifting the ban embrace that Twitter should register its enterprise in Nigeria and have a employees presence within the nation.

Mr Buhari’s administration has proven little respect for the rule of legislation and freedom of speech, with numerous journalists and activists locked up merely for criticising the federal government.

Banning Twitter fully is a barely hid try by the federal government to stifle voices of criticism, and Nigerians have good purpose to be fearful.

However the energy of Large Tech to make arbitrary selections about who will get to say what, when and the way, is equally troubling.

It raises questions on policing speech and censoring unpopular voices, amid the necessity for open public debate in a free democratic society.

If it was authoritarian for the Nigerian authorities to ban the usage of Twitter, it was much more problematic for an American swivelling in a chair in Silicon Valley to poke their finger into the interior affairs of a sovereign African state.

Extra Letters from Africa:

Comply with us on Twitter @BBCAfrica, on Fb at BBC Africa or on Instagram at bbcafrica

A composite image showing the BBC Africa logo and a man reading on his smartphone.

A composite picture exhibiting the BBC Africa emblem and a person studying on his smartphone.


Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.